Fish is to ocean as dog is to ... oh, never mind

Tougher SAT dumps analogies
Wednesday, September 01, 2004 • BY KELLY HEYBOER •Star-Ledger Staff

Attention Class of 2006: Forget analogies.

If you're getting ready to take the SAT this spring, brush up on your Algebra II, absolute values, functional notations, and negative and fractional exponents. Practice finding errors in sentences and rewriting paragraphs.

Above all, learn to write a solid essay in 25 minutes.

The College Board yesterday gave the public its first peek of the new version of the SAT, which is to debut in March. The overhauled college entrance exam will feature a new writing section, an essay, more reading passages and higher- level math questions.

Analogies (such as "soporific is to sleep as fertilizer is to growth") are gone. Quantitative comparisons (math questions that ask test takers to compare or estimate numbers) also will be eliminated.

The changes -- which will expand the test from 3 hours to 3 hours, 45 minutes -- are designed to make the nation's largest college entrance exam a better predictor of how well students will do in college, said College Board President Gaston Caperton.

"The new SAT will continue to assess how students apply what they have learned in school," Caperton said. "With the addition of the writing section, it will be even more valuable in assessing the academic skills students need to succeed in college and in today's work force."

The College Board, a nonprofit group that oversees the SAT, announced it would overhaul the test in 2002 amid growing complaints that the exam was flawed and a threat that the University of California was planning to develop its own entrance exam.

College Board researchers spent the last two years trying out ideas and administering 45,000 field tests before settling on the final version, said Photo Anagnostopoulos, the College Board's senior vice president for product development.

"The guiding principle was what is best for the students," she said. "We researched this to the nth degree."

The new test will have three parts. A new writing section, a critical reading (formerly called verbal) section and a math section. Each will be scored on a 200- to 800-point scale. A perfect score will be a 2400, instead of the old 1600.

Other specifications include:

 

The 25-minute essay will always be the first question on the exam. Research showed students did better when they got the hand- written essay out of the way first, rather than tackling it in the middle or at the end of the exam, College Board officials said.

 

The rest of the writing section will include 35 minutes of multiple- choice questions in which students must identify grammatical errors, improve poorly written sentences and rewrite paragraphs.

 

In the critical reading section, students will answer 48 questions about fictional, narrative and scientific passages they read. They also will answer 19 sentence completion questions.

 

The majority of the questions in the 70-minute math section will still be multiple choice. But students will have to solve and write in the answers to 10 questions.

 

Students in the East and Midwest will get a different essay question than students in the West. That will discourage students in the East from taking advantage of the time difference to leak the topic of the essay to friends in California on test day, College Board officials said.

The essay section will be graded by an army of college professors and high school teachers who will read the papers over the Internet.

College Board officials encouraged current high school seniors to take the current version of the SAT this fall or in January. The new version, which debuts March 12, is supposed to be for the Class of 2006. But current seniors will be permitted to take the new test, too, if they miss earlier test dates.

Most colleges will begin requiring the new version of the SAT for students applying to start college in the fall of 2006.

Grayce Mei, entering her junior year West Windsor-Plainsboro High School South, will be among the first wave of students to take the tougher test in the spring.

"I am a little worried but not that much," Mei said.

She already scored 1460 on the current SAT and took an early practice version of the new exam. She plans to take the old test again one last time, then sit for the new exam in the spring.

The College Board also released yesterday SAT averages for last year's graduating class that showed scores in New Jersey and the rest of the nation held steady last year. The average verbal score nationally rose a point to 508 out of a maximum of 800, while the average math score fell a point to 518.

In New Jersey, the average student scored a 501 on the verbal section, the same as last year. Students averaged a 514 on the math section, one point less than last year.

Though the average scores for Mexican-American and Hispanic students improved slightly, scores for women and minorities continued to fall well below white male students.

The anti-testing group FairTest and other SAT critics said the latest numbers continue to prove the exam is biased and does not predict academic success.

"The so-called 'new' SAT, to be introduced next year, fails to address any of these problems," said Bob Schaeffer, public education director of the Massachusetts-based FairTest.


Staff writer Bev McCarron contributed to this report.
Copyright 2004 The Star-Ledger. Used by NJ.com with permission.

Return to Articles page